67 Problems of Labour in India
This is the closing chapter of book 33. It consolidates the major problems of Indian labour — bringing together themes from across the book into a single diagnostic synthesis.
67.1 A Diagnostic Map
The problems of Indian labour fall into ten broad clusters.
| # | Cluster | Core problem |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Informalisation | ~80-90% of workers without formal protection |
| 2 | Underemployment | Hidden in self-employment and casual work |
| 3 | Low female participation | Untapped half of the workforce |
| 4 | Skills mismatch | Education output not matched to demand |
| 5 | Wage inadequacy | Many workers below living wage |
| 6 | Working conditions | Health, safety, hours often substandard |
| 7 | Migration without protection | Inter-state mobility outside the IR architecture |
| 8 | Child labour | Persistent in certain sectors |
| 9 | Gender, caste, religious discrimination | Persistent gaps |
| 10 | Climate vulnerability | Workers exposed to heat, displacement |
67.2 Informalisation — The Master Problem
The largest single problem. ~80-90% of Indian workers are in informal employment — without written contracts, without statutory social security, without effective representation.
| Face | Examples |
|---|---|
| Self-employed informal | Own-account, family workers, street vendors |
| Wage-labour informal | Casual labour in construction, agriculture |
| Contract labour in formal sector | Through contractors, often without statutory entitlements |
| Platform / gig | Independent-contractor classification |
| Domestic workers | Largely outside protective architecture |
67.3 Underemployment
While open unemployment in India is low (~3.2%), underemployment is widespread:
- Time-related — workers wanting more hours
- Skill-mismatched — graduates in low-skill jobs
- Income-inadequate — working but below subsistence
The Lewis-model surplus labour persists in agriculture and informal services.
67.4 Low Female Labour-Force Participation
Despite recent rises, female LFPR (~42% overall, ~25% urban) is among the lowest in major economies. Drivers and remedies:
| Driver | Remedy |
|---|---|
| Unpaid care work | Childcare infrastructure, parental leave |
| Safety concerns | Public safety, transport, workplace safety |
| Cultural constraints | Norms change, education, role models |
| Discrimination in hiring and pay | Equal-remuneration enforcement |
| Lack of part-time and flexible options | Workplace flexibility |
| Skill gaps in tech and STEM | Targeted skill programmes |
67.5 Skills Mismatch
A large share of graduates is reportedly not employable in the formal sector. Causes: poor school quality, mismatch between curriculum and industry, weak vocational training, low-quality higher education at the tail. Remedies: NEP 2020, NSDM, sector skill councils, industry-academia linkage.
67.6 Wage Inadequacy
Despite minimum-wage laws, many workers — especially in informal sector — earn below subsistence. The Code on Wages, 2019 introduces a floor wage but its level has been criticised as low. Real-wage growth has lagged productivity growth.
67.7 Poor Working Conditions
Especially in the informal sector — long hours, hazardous environments, no social security, no rest days. The Factories Act and OSH Code apply only to a minority of Indian workplaces.
67.8 Migration without Protection
The COVID-19 reverse migration of 2020 exposed the architecture’s failure. Despite ISMW Act, 1979, most inter-state migrants travelled and worked informally. Recent reforms — eShram, Code on Social Security, ONORC — partially address this.
67.9 Child Labour
Despite the 2016 amendment to the Child Labour Act, child labour persists in:
- Family enterprises (legal)
- Domestic work
- Hazardous occupations (illegal but underground)
- Street work — vending, ragpicking
The 2011 Census recorded ~1 crore working children; estimates suggest substantial undercount.
67.10 Discrimination — Gender, Caste, Religion
Despite Articles 14, 15, 16 and the Equal Remuneration Act, persistent gaps:
- Gender wage gap ~24% in regular employment
- Caste-based occupational segregation and wage gaps
- Muslim-Hindu employment gaps in similar occupations
67.11 Climate Vulnerability
Climate change exposes Indian workers to:
- Heat stress (construction, agriculture, mining)
- Flood-related job losses (coastal, riverine)
- Drought-induced rural unemployment
- Air-pollution health effects (urban, industrial)
- Coal-sector displacement (just transition needed)
The OSH Code introduces some heat-related provisions; broader response is in policy formulation.
67.12 Other Problems
| Problem | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Unemployment among educated youth | ~13% graduate UR |
| Rural distress | Agricultural over-employment, low wages |
| Indebtedness | Debt-bondage, distress migration |
| Health and nutrition | Anaemia, TB, occupational diseases |
| Bonded labour | Persistent despite 1976 Act |
| Sexual harassment | POSH Act 2013 — implementation gaps |
| Mental health at work | Rising recognition; stigma persists |
| Quality of public-sector jobs | Bureaucratic; low performance pressure |
67.13 Roots of the Problems
The proximate causes connect to deeper structural roots:
| Root | What it produces |
|---|---|
| Slow industrialisation | Few formal jobs created |
| Education-skill gaps | Skills mismatch |
| Capital-intensive growth | Low employment elasticity |
| Weak enforcement | Even existing protections under-delivered |
| Social hierarchies | Caste, gender, religion gaps reproduced in labour markets |
| Low productivity | Wages constrained |
67.14 Policy Responses
Indian policy has responded through multiple channels:
| Channel | Initiatives |
|---|---|
| Labour-law reform | Four labour codes |
| Skill development | PMKVY, NSDM, ITIs |
| Employment guarantee | MGNREGA |
| Social security extension | Code on Social Security; PM-SYM, APY |
| Manufacturing push | Make in India, PLI, MSME support |
| Female empowerment | Maternity Benefit Act, POSH, BetiBachao-BetiPadhao |
| Migration governance | eShram, ONORC |
| Climate transition | Renewable jobs, just transition framework |
67.15 Looking Ahead
The Indian labour market faces a critical decade. The demographic dividend window is narrowing; technology is reshaping jobs faster than ever; climate transition is beginning; female participation is rising; and the labour-code framework is being operationalised. Whether India creates decent work for all by mid-century — the SDG-8 goal — depends on the labour, social and economic policies of the next two decades.
The labour question is, in the end, the development question for India: how to convert a young, large, diverse workforce into productive, dignified employment for all.
67.16 Practice Questions
Show answer
Show answer
Show answer
Show answer
Show answer
Show answer
Show answer
Show answer
- Ten problem clusters: informalisation, underemployment, low female LFPR, skills mismatch, wage inadequacy, working conditions, migration, child labour, discrimination, climate vulnerability.
- Indian open UR ~3.2%; underemployment widespread.
- Female LFPR ~42% (rising); urban female ~25%.
- Gender wage gap — women earn ~76% of men’s.
- Educated UR ~13%; youth UR ~10%.
- Roots: slow industrialisation, skills gap, capital-intensive growth, weak enforcement, social hierarchies, low productivity.
- Policy responses: labour codes, skill missions, MGNREGA, social security extension, manufacturing push, female empowerment, migration governance, climate transition.
- The labour question is the development question for India.
- SDG-8: decent work for all; full and productive employment.